I stumbled across a blog that led me to various other sites while I looked further into the phenomenon: Purity Balls vs The Purity Myth. This intrigued me for a variety of reasons, which will likely become obvious in this blog if you don’t know my take on this already. I had intended to just comment on this post which also leads to that post, but was writing so much I figured I might as well write my own post about it.
Basically, Purity Balls are this big to-do in the States where daughters pledge to be pure to their fathers in a ceremony that is very religious and also rather wedding-like. They are apparently even government funded, as is America's abstinence-ed in school (as opposed to our sex-ed in Canada).
The Purity Myth is about how the word “purity” is used as an equivalent of being a virgin and degrading women to just physicality, rather than being a good person in character. Also there is no concrete medical definition for virgin; it has a social meaning that changes depending on the person (Virgin status has been known to be defined as anything from no hugging or kissing to a “home run”). There is a book by the same title written by Jessica Valenti discussing this topic.
Apparently one of the founders say that they started having purity balls more as a right of passage for fathers. As a means to get them more involved with their daughter’s lives and to help them grow from being a child into being a young woman by being a positive influence and good role model and a support system. I like the theory behind it, but in some cases certain aspects are too gender biased, rituals are too structured for universality, and sometimes things are taken to the extreme in a way I don't personally agree with.
1.) Why is it only daughters making this pledge and not the sons, too? This reminds me of the double-standard of “studs” vs “sluts”. That guys who "score" are macho and manly and to be respected, while women who have multiple sex-partners are whores to be ridiculed and derided. These purity balls should be for both genders with an equal importance, because without that it seems like the message is that guys are not sinning when they have sex but girls are, and therefore it is only the females who lose their “purity”.
2.) Why is it only father-figures and not mothers that these pledges can be made to? It essentially says that females cannot be trusted with their own, or their child’s, well-being. This is reminiscent of the Regency/Victorian times where women were not considered intelligent enough to handle funds or property or guardianship, and so “their” possessions/children/wards were controlled by the men in their life, being passed from fathers to husbands, etc. giving these men the right to spend the money themselves or marry off their daughters for whatever reason the men pleased. To resolve this, allow the girls/boys to choose who they wish to make their pledge to -be it parents, friends, family members, God, themselves- rather than restricting them to just a man.
3. Shouldn’t both parents already be trying to have a good relationship with their children? If the intent is to get parents more involved in their children's lives, I think the only parents who would get involved are the ones who already care enough to be involved. Having a ball is not going to make an uncaring parent bother taking the time to participate, and even if socially shamed into doing it, more likely the pledge is nothing but a public façade. By making purity balls a community event it is possible that in time people will become better parents due to their own childhoods, but until then maybe some of the unlucky kids should be "sponsored" by an adult who will actually be there when needed.
4.) Why make the pledge to your parent anyways? Giving control over your sex-life to another person just does not seem like the smartest idea to me. The person who it should matter most to is yourself, and no one can take care of it better because you are the one who has the most to lose. To help them be responsible for themselves, teens should be taught about how to make informed decisions and have an open discussion about the consequences of having sex before they are ready and how to know when they are ready.
5.) Why are purity balls all faith-based and require putting flowers at the foot of a cross? I am sure there are people out there who are waiting for marriage for reasons outside of religion who need a support system as much as a religious person might. And I think God cares more about the promise being made than being given flowers, so the symbolism of the act is rather irrelevant. Allow each girl or boy to decide how they want to show a physical manifestation of their promise if they so choose. Someone could be allergic to flowers!
6.) Why must there be white ball gowns? Some girls do not like to dress up, and white has different meanings in different cultures. This is yet another mindless ritual that could cause some people to forgo taking part. I love dressing up but I look horrible in white, ball gowns are expensive, and half my friends would rather die than put on a dress. I think the dress code should be just dressing nicely, even if that means pants, and allowing them to choose the colour that makes them confident in themselves.
7) Why are girls as young as six taking part in these balls? This ceremony should not be taken lightly or forced upon girls who have not been able to converse openly and fully comprehend what they are promising. Trying to shove your own beliefs on your kid could lead them to rebel –either obviously or secretly- or do things out of fear when they aren’t yet ready which could adversely effect them in many ways. It is alright to start discussing purity balls with your child at whatever age they can start understanding, but it should be something they can grow up with thinking about and discussing until they choose to make the promise.
8.) Why is purity being used as the equivalent of virginity? The bible says to be pure in heart, mind, tongue, etc as well as in body. Rather than making these ceremonies all about chastity until marriage, there should be equal emphasis on just being a good person -to refrain from swearing, or bullying, or everyday evil thoughts. This way the message being sent to young girls and boys it not that sex causes impurity, but your character and actions. Thoughts come before actions, so the mind should be considered just as important as the body when it comes to purity. And should someone be raped, he or she has basically been told their entire life that they are impure because their virginity was taken in a violent act even if they have not had impure thoughts; this could completely ruin their faith in the church, in their family, and in themselves.
9.) Why are those who lose their virginity before marriage ostracized? It seems that this support system can swing the other way for those who are considered to have broken their promise. It can get to the point where someone is publically shunned, assaulted, and possibly even asked to leave the church community. People make mistakes, but God still loves and forgives them, therefore the “support system” should be there to help that person deal with the emotional upheaval and help them “get back on track” should they so desire.
What do you think about purity balls? Do you love them or hate them or stand somewhere in-between? Have you been to a purity ball or know someone who has? Would you ever consider having a purity ball for yourself or your child?
SUMR
***Disclaimer: I have not heard of purity balls before this, and therefore have obviously never attended one, nor have I read Jessica's book or seen the documentary based on her book, so I am only basing my thoughts on anything I have recently come across on the internet that relates to this topic. I apologize if some of my information is inaccurate.***
Recent Comments